Skip to content

Samurai And Knights Dbq Essay

Unformatted text preview: Samurai and Knights:Were the Similarities Greater Than the Differences ​ The time for Japan and Europe was in trouble. The fall of the Roman Empire occurred and Japan’s imperial court weakened. Which then led up to breaking up both of medieval societies Were the samurai and knights more alike than opposites? As a result, feudal systems joined. Like the vikings. The samurai and knights were more similar than different in three wide areas; social position, training and armor, and honor and death. The social position of samurai and knights was one way of their similarities. In both societies, these warriors ranked in the center (​ Doc.A​ ). Also,they both owed loyalty and military service to who’ve they serve. Although, the knights were placed 5th and the samurai were placed 4rth (​ Doc.B​ ). Even though they have a slight difference in ranking, there is more evidence that proves that shows more similarities than differences in social position. Training and armor are also samurais and knights reason with greater similarities. Both samurai and knights went through extensive training. And they both learned their code of conduct, had some religious practice and were loyal to their masters. (​ Doc.C​ ). They both wore armor, but knight wore metal armor and the samurai wore armor that was made of silk (​ Doc.D​ ). Even though there is a small difference of what kind or what was it made up, most of the evidence shows us that they both used armor for protection. Both samurai and knights lived by a moral code and lived honorable lives, but they have a very different view about death. Both warriors emphasized loyalty and moral life,have a code of conduct, and that they both have a soft side (​ Doc.E​ ). In transition, this was a big difference between the knights and samurai. The samurai were Budda, so they believed in reincarnation. They thought death was no big deal, you live, then you’ll die. Knights however, once they know their a sin or became one, before they die he would ask god to forgive him, so he could make it to ​ heaven​ (​ Doc.F​ )​ .​ To summarize​ , k​ nights thought death ended life, samurai they thought/know they would/could reincarnate. Samurai and knights are more similar than different in social position training and armor and heir code of conduct. Although they have a different views of death and slightly religion, these pieces of evidence shows that the similarities are​ greater than the differences. ...
View Full Document

Samurai And Knights Essay

Japan is 5,313 miles away from Europe, is it possible that both their warriors have similarities? After the Roman Empire fell, it left Europe in pieces. Around the globe, Japan faced the same problem. Clans were constantly fighting each other for power and land. To keep order in society, both Japan and Europe started a system called feudalism. Feudalism is when Lords gave some of their lands to lesser nobles, in exchange for military service. The nobles trained warriors to fight for their land. In exchange for land or food, the warriors swore loyalty to their noble. The warriors of Europe were the knights, where the warriors of Japan were the samurai. Samurai and Knights, where the similarities greater than the differences? Samurai and knights are more similar in these three areas, training, armor, social structure, and honor code.
The training of knights and samurai are actually very similar, and so is their armor. Samurai started to train in childhood, along with knights who started at four or five. They both learned some sort of sword fighting, Japan with bamboo and Europe with wooden swords. Knights and samurai trainees learned religious instruction too. At age fourteen samurai graduate at a ceremony called genpuku, but the knights have 7 more years to go. Samurai and Knights both have armor, but that's not all. They both have many pieces of their armor. One key difference to their armor is that the samurai had an arm that was free to move around. While the knights were in full body armor, they could barely move around. Knights fully relied on their horses, who let the knights move around. If the horse dies, the knight will have to move on their feet (imagine moving around without bending your limbs. Knights and Samurai are very similar with training and armor, though there are slight differences.
The social structure of Medieval Japan and  Europe are very similar, and so is the warrior class's loyalty. In the social pyramid, both samurai and knights have similar positions. They are both under a lord, or a daimyo (a feudal lord of Japan). If you look at the social pyramid you might think that they are different,...

Loading: Checking Spelling

0%

Read more

Samurai vs Knight Essay

1804 words - 7 pages Samurai vs Knight Many people often see little similarity between the country of Japan and Europe. However, there are actually several similarities between these two countries. In fact, Reischauer and Jansen note that Feudal Japan had departed so far from East Asian norms that it was more similar to medieval Europe than it was to China. Thus, the knight of Europe and the samurai of Japan despite a lack of contact with one another...

Legacy of the Samurai: The characteristics, philosophy, and history of the samurai.

2578 words - 10 pages Legacy of the SamuraiThe characteristics, philosophy,and history of the samurai.For seven centuries, the samurai ruled Japan as the powerful warrior class. As a class of warriors and knights, they led society in feudal Japan. The loyalty to his lord was much more important than his allegiance to his friends, family and even the emperor. Their philosophy was one liberated him from fear,...

Japanese Martial Arts

1301 words - 5 pages Japanese Martial Arts In Japan, especially during the earlier periods of Japanese history such as the Tokugawa, physical adeptness was much revered and valued. This was mainly because of the fact that these strengths were the basis on which much of the population depended upon for survival during these fairly turbulent periods. Throughout time, Japan has been a very organized and scrupulous society, and even its style of physical...

Japanese History (ancient)

1775 words - 7 pages FEUDAL JAPANTIMELINE710-794 NARA ERA794-1156 HEIAN JAPAN1156-1180 TAIRA RULE (EARLY MILITARY HOUSE)1185-1333 KAMAKURA BAKUFU1333-1336 DISPUTED CONTROL1336-1467 ASHIKAGA BAKUFURise of Feudalism: In contrast to Europe, where feudalism declined as centralized national monarchies grew stronger, in Japan...

Stars of war

841 words - 3 pages Tong PAGE \* MERGEFORMAT 2 Nicholas TongMs. BonnetteAP English23 September 2014Stars of WarFor many centuries, objects were given to military personal, such as knights, soldiers, or even samurai in order to distinguish their skill, dedication, or bravery. These objects usually give their owner respect and honor from his peers. Throughout different time periods and regions, these objects,...

The Western Movie Genre

1398 words - 6 pages Westerns are the most important genre of the American film industry, a reflective tribute to the early days of the grand, wild American frontier. They are one of the oldest, most prevailing and versatile genres and one of the classically American genres in their mythic origins. The popularity of westerns has changed over time. Their most productive period was in the 1930s to the 1960s, and most lately in the 90s, there was a restoration of the...

Compare and Contrast- Japanese and Western Feudalism

562 words - 2 pages Feudalism was very common political system that was used greatly in the postclassical era. There were significant differences between the Japanese form of feudalism and the western (European) form of feudalism. They were both developed around similar times between the 9th and 12th centuries; nevertheless, they developed into two very distinct forms which contained differences despite their few similarities. Why did they develop differently you...

Governmental systems

1327 words - 5 pages What is government? A government is supposed to benefit the people of the state. In most cases the rich and powerful use the government to benefit themselves, but the ideal government would benefit all people. These social structures have different froms. Democracy, Dictatorships, Feudalism and Communism are all forms of government that have been used in the history and are...

"Chronicles of a Death Foretold": Theme Paper

581 words - 2 pages Honor is something that human beings have practiced throughout history. It can even be considered the oldest tradition. From the chivalrous knights who's honor code was their life, to the great samurai warriors of Japan that in order to save lost honor, they had to commit kamikaze, which was their way of suicide. In Gabriel...

"The Rape of Nanking," by Iris Chang.

2663 words - 11 pages "Maps can really point to places where life is evil now: Nanking; Dachau." History is based on perspective. World War II started on December 7, 1941, the Japanese Imperial Army attacked Pearl Harbor. Europeans go back a couple years to September 1, 1939, when Germany attacked Poland. Africans see it earlier on the invasion of Ethiopia in 1935....

Njal's Saga

1686 words - 7 pages Njal’s Saga is a long and epic tale of jealousy, treachery, and manipulation. The previous book that we read, The Nibelungenlied, also featured these similar plot elements. Njal’s Saga contains several characters that have close similarities to those in The Nibelungenlied. In The Nibelungenlied, there is a mighty fighter named Siegfried. As a proven warrior, Siegfried possesses great strength and an ego that is equally as great. Halfway through...